Casalonga UPC rules of procedure
Powered by Casalonga

Rule 242Decision of the Court of Appeal

1. The Court of Appeal shall either reject the appeal or set the decision or order aside totally or in part substituting its own decision or order, including an order for costs both in respect of the proceedings at first instance and on appeal.

2. The Court of Appeal may:

(a) exercise any power within the competence of the Court of First Instance;

(b) in exceptional circumstances refer the action back to the Court of First Instance for decision or for retrial [Rule 243 [1] ]. It shall not normally be an exceptional circumstance justifying a referral back that the Court of First Instance failed to decide an issue which it is necessary for the Court of Appeal to decide on appeal.

Rule 243 – Referral back
(1) If an appeal pursuant to Article 73 is well-founded, the Court of Appeal shall revoke the decision of the
Please login to continue reading.

Registering with the site

You have requested to take part in a forum reserved for registered visitors.

Personal identifiers

Enter your personal information here. You will receive a registration confirmation shortly by email. Such email may have been considered as spam. If you do not find it in your inbox nor in your spam, please send an email to

(Your password must contain at least 6 characters.)

Required fields are indicated with a « * »

New visitor ?


1. The decision referring an action back to the Court of First Instance shall specify whether the same panel whose earlier decision or order is revoked shall deal further with the action or whether another panel shall be appointed by the presiding judge of the division concerned.
2. Where an action is referred back to the Court of First Instance, the Court shall be bound by the decision of the Court of Appeal and its ratio decidendi.